Every game counts, except for the ones we determine don’t matter, under the guise of not evaluating losses. The end of the College Football season has always had its ways of frustrating us on one level or another. Bowl games were set up in a weird way, where the best teams didn’t necessarily play each other, and everyone was proud to play on January 1st.
I know, I know. This New Years Eve is going to be so awesome, watching College Football through confetti…but really, is it? Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want to go back to the old days of split-titles and what-not, but the more we try to solve the problem, the more we realize there’s no perfect solution. I mean, it’s nice. We reward four regular season achievers with a playoff, distinguish four other games as very important, and spend our December and early January evenings watching games of waning importance that feature slightly above average to fairly good teams.
That seems cool, but the undercard action is borderline fatiguing, and there’s such a gap between the motivation you’re going to have for a National Semifinal versus an “Access Bowl”. Ask Nick Saban about his Alabama team sleepwalking into those consultation games. There’s gap between the Access Bowls and kicking off in Orlando at 11 AM on the first day of the year, but being left out of the Peach Bowl isn’t quite the same as being five and wondering why a committee thought four was better than you.
That might be a problem. For the second year in a row, I’d have to assume we’re going to see some sort of subjective cut line, and there will be a solid argument for a team playing in Pasadena1Or one of those other prestigious non-championship participating games. I’m assuming a Big Ten team or Stanford to be competing for a title. Ohio State and Notre Dame have only lost close games to top opponents, Stanford dropped one to an Oregon team that’s much better than their record and one hard-to-forgive road contest at Northwestern, and North Carolina is begging forgiveness for their season opening loss to South Carolina and the Ole Ball Coach2That’s Steve Spurrier, who resigned in-season this year..
There’s a few ways to look at this. Chalk makes it easy and chaos makes it chaotic.
It’s undefeated Clemson and once-defeated North Carolina. Clemson finally cleared the hurdles created by Florida State and South Carolina in the past, and find themselves in the ACC Championship game for the first time in a while. Quarterback DeShaun Watson will take the stage with an outside chance at the Heisman Trophy, so head coach Dabo Swinney will set him up to shine. North Carolina has Marquis Williams, and he’s been nothing short of sensational behind center for Larry Fedora’s team, who enters the weekend on an 11-game winning streak of their own.
Chalk: Clemson wins and they’re in. Wins over Notre Dame, Florida State, and North Carolina will make the fact they schedule Wofford as meaningless as Alabama’s loss at home to Ole Miss.
Chaos: North Carolina wins, and you start comparing them to teams on the couch this weekend. Ohio State was underwhelming, despite holding the top spot until we recognized the committee’s rankings over the AP’s. The Tar Heels didn’t play Florida State this season, and schedule two FCS opponents. This might come down to style points, and while most would have to think simply taking down Clemson would do the trick, we know the aforementioned Buckeyes made an “All Sales Final” pitch to the committee in the Big Ten title game a year ago.
Big Ten Championship
With all due respect to their recent success, it will be a battle of little brothers in Indianapolis to crown a Big Ten Champion. Iowa is unbeaten, but no one believes they are what it says they are on paper. They’re hanging their hat on a non-conference win over Pitt and victories over a few decent intra division rivals. Michigan State, on the other hand, has been the best team on the field in every game they’ve played this season. They were better than the Cornhuskers, who won on a very controversial play, and they were better than the Buckeyes, who they dominated in their own building, despite the game coming down to a walk-off field goal.
Chalk: The winner goes to the College Football Playoff. Few would argue that.
Chaos: Enough people might get it in their head that if Iowa wins, do you automatically deem them better than all of the 1-loss teams. Undefeated should eliminate that noise. You could hold the Nebraska loss against Michigan State, but wins at Michigan, Ohio State, and Oregon3You could mitigate this victory a little bit by suggesting they didn’t play the same Oregon that knocked off Stanford, but it was still a good win for Michigan State., not to mention Iowa on the big stage should quiet all of that noise. The only chaos here would be an ugly game, and an ugly game didn’t keep Texas out of the 2010 BCS Championship, in the era known as that of The BCS.
Pac 12 Championship
USC has four losses, and they fired their head coach earlier this season, but bounced back under interim-turned-full-time head coach Clay Helton. Stanford has some momentum after the big win in their season finale over Notre Dame, and they’ll be playing close to home this weekend.
Chalk: I’m not sure it matters, but if Stanford loses, they are out. If they win, they are scoreboard watching.
Chaos: The top teams bottom out in their conference championship games, and the committee has three teams locked in, Oklahoma and the champions from the Big Ten and ACC. Fourth spot is up for grabs, with 2-loss Alabama, 1-loss Ohio State, and the 2-loss Cardinal reaching for it.
Alabama was able to convincingly beat Wisconsin on a neutral field to start the year and lost early to Ole Miss at home. They took care of business versus the rest of the SEC, but the jury is really deliberating hard on just how good the conference was in 2015. Florida has had a good run under first-year coach Jim McElwain, surviving an unexpected year-long suspension for their opening day starting quarterback to win the SEC East, but a poor showing versus Florida State last week does not inspire anyone into believing they’ll best Alabama in Atlanta on Saturday.
Chalk: Alabama is very likely on the top line with a win and all the way out with a loss to the Gators.
Chaos: There promises to be a lot of Gator fans in Columbus. Realistically, a Florida win is the only obvious route for Ohio State (or Stanford) to reach the College Football Playoff, but then what do you make of a 2-loss Florida team.
Basically, because rarely does anyone ever find themselves held accountable for being wrong, I’m going to take a stab at slotting the Semis and the Access Bowls.
Orange Bowl (National Semifinal)
Michigan State vs. Clemson
Cotton Bowl (National Semifinal)
Oklahoma vs. Alabama
Ohio State vs. Stanford
Baylor vs. Florida
Iowa vs. Notre Dame
Houston vs. Florida State
[ + ]
|1.||↑||Or one of those other prestigious non-championship participating games. I’m assuming a Big Ten team or Stanford|
|2.||↑||That’s Steve Spurrier, who resigned in-season this year.|
|3.||↑||You could mitigate this victory a little bit by suggesting they didn’t play the same Oregon that knocked off Stanford, but it was still a good win for Michigan State.|