We’re going into week five of the college football season. There have been some exciting games played in the SEC including Texas A&M beating Arkansas in overtime and Florida’s miraculous wins over Kentucky and Tennessee. But what have we learned so far?
Tennessee is 3-1 but the Volunteers could just as easily be 1-3. They had an amazing comeback win against Georgia Tech and hung on for dear life against UMass. Georgia Tech is understandable. But UMass? I would have thought that after bungling the end of the game against Florida that Butch Jones and his team would have come out prepared against UMass. No. I was wrong. Jones didn’t have his team prepared for UMass.
Here’s what we know – Butch Jones is in over his head at Tennessee.
Sure he’s won nine games a year at Tennessee but he just as easily could have led his teams to double-digit win totals. Jones is a capable coach. He wouldn’t have had success at Cincinnati and Central Michigan if he couldn’t coach. But now that the Tennessee brand helps him land four- and five-star talent, he seems to have become complacent.
Alabama Is Still Really Good
We’ve been told about the demise of Alabama. They tell us that there’s a quarterback controversy. They tell us that the defense is on par with previous Crimson Tide units. We’re told that Nick Saban’s success at Alabama is the result of the SEC taking a few steps back.
Here’s what we know – Alabama is still really good.
Don’t believe the jealous rhetoric. The defense that everyone is questioning was strong enough to knock Deondre Francois out for the year. The quarterback controversy that we’re told about is wishful thinking. Jalen Hurts is doing what’s asked of him. And besides. When was the last time a Saban-led Alabama team was built around the quarterback? As for the quality of the SEC? Maybe it has taken a step back but Alabama is as good as it’s ever been.
Just ask Vanderbilt.
Where Have All The Coaches Gone?
Yes. The conference has taken a step back. The SEC East hasn’t fielded a competitive team in the SEC title game in what seems like forever. The SEC West appears to be Alabama And The Six Dwarfs. So what’s the problem?
Here’s what we know – The conference lacks quality coaches.
If you want to find the good teams in any conference, just start with the coaches. The SEC East has Kirby Smart, Jim McElwain, Derek Mason, Mark Stoops, Barry Odom, and Will Muschamp. While I think McElwain is a fantastic coach with tons of potential, that group is nothing to write home about. As for the SEC West, we find Nick Saban, Gus Malzahn, Dan Mullen, Ed Orgeron, Bret Bielema, and Matt Luke (for now). Saban is obviously Saban, Malzahn’s seat grows hotter each season, and Mullen was the hot new commodity until Smart and Georgia beat the Bulldogs down. As for Orgeron, Bielema, and Luke? Who in need of a coach would be beating their doors down? Nobody, that’s who.
This is the biggest problem in the conference. Only a couple of teams really want to invest in a football coach. It’s not acceptable for your AD to say, “Well, we can’t get Saban, or Fisher, or Swinney, so we might as well save a few bucks and go cheap.” This isn’t acceptable.
Comment on this story in our free forum.
E-mail Seth at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter @SethMerenbloom.