Tag Archives: Jay Williams

Sorry Duke, Virginia is the New Taste in College Basketball

Reading some of national reporting on college basketball, particularly Virginia basketball, it might be easy to conclude that there was a crisis in college basketball. It would be easy to conclude that Virginia basketball was an infection slowly killing college basketball. It would be easy to conclude that Virginia was leading NCAA basketball down the path to attention deficit disorder-driven doom.

Such a conclusion couldn’t be more wrong.

I watched Duke play Florida State the other day. It is hard not to be impressed by the embarrassment of riches Coach K has brought to Durham. Duke starts 4 freshmen. At least 2 of those 4 will be one-and-dones. The other 2 could spend a second season in Durham pretending to be college students, but it is not likely. Smart money says all four call it quits on going to class in January and conclude their stints at the NBA’s minor league franchise-in-residence at Durham after March Madness concludes.

As I watched the track meet with FSU, I couldn’t help but wonder what Shane Battier, Carlos Boozer and Jay Williams thought. I can’t imagine what Bobby Hurley, Christan Laettner and Grant Hill think. I am sure they are happy with the continued success of the program. Duke is an unquestioned big dpg in NCAA basketball. However, watching Duke play basketball today has very little in common with Duke basketball that put the Blue Devils on the map. It looks nothing like the game that Battier, Booozer, Laettner, and Hurley played. Funny, I don’t remember many reporters griping about too much defense when defense was Duke’s calling card.

The Duke of old was known for discipline. Hard-nosed, aggressive man-to-man defense was Duke’s differentiation. While Duke had very talented players back in the day, they lived and died with their defense and the offense it so frequently spawned. Prior to the current incarnation of Duke basketball, players went to class and graduated with college degrees.

Not any more. The Duke of today is a staging area for NBA players. A way station, a holding bin. Duke no longer has a brand or calling card other than a roster stacked with kids who have no interest in a Duke education. Instead, they have every intention of leaving Durham before the first commencement ceremonies of their college “careers.” Remember when Coach K wouldn’t raise a championship banner in Cameron Indoor if a player on his team had not finished his degree? Yeah, those days are over.

Watching Duke play these days is like any other play ground game. it is festival of 1-on-1 moves and dunks. Duke’s defense is more happenstance than strategy & execution. When ridiculously talented players log enough minutes, eventually they will be in a position to make a remarkable play. Duke’s defensive success is more like looking down and finding a 4-leaf clover than the result of a well deployed plan.

On the other hand, I just got back from the Virginia/North Carolina game in Charlottesville. UNC came into today’s game averaging 85 points per game. They scored just over half of their average today as Virginia dominated the Tar Heels for the second year in a row in John Paul Jones Arena.

In past two games combined against Virginia, the Heels have scored 92 points for a per-game average of 46. That doesn’t happen by accident. It also is not a result of Virginia’s roster being stacked with 5-star, future NBA lottery picks. Rather it is the result of a program that is committed to winning differently and generally has its way setting tempo and controlling the pace of play.

Unlike Duke, Virginia wins based on stellar execution at both ends of the floor. They win by playing the best defense in the country. They win by frustrating offensive juggernauts used to having their way running up and down the court doing tomahawk and windmill dunks. UNC didn’t have any windmill jams on Saturday. Instead they got their butts kicked at both ends of the court by a team that, on paper, had no business staying within 20 points of the Tar Heels. What’s not to love about that?

David slaying Goliath has always been a popular theme in college athletics. Until Virginia started averaging close to 30 wins a season, no one ever evaluated David’s style points for how he slew Goliath. That Virginia fans went as crazy over 3 uNC shot clock violations as they did for De’Andre Hunter’s thunder jam over Joel Barry shows me that Virginia fans appreciate the full breadth of the college game.

Virginia can’t win playing UNC or Duke basketball, so they don’t. Instead, they play aggressive defense. They make the extra pass on offense. They play Virginia basketball. True basketball fans should at least appreciate if not relish the fact the Coach Tony Bennett has found a way to run with and beat the big dogs by intentionally not playing their game. Strategy and execution should be as appreciated as a part of college basketball as a break-away slam.

I suspect those who grimace at the way Virginia has creeped into the top tier of basketball programs are the same folks who like to see a winning score at the US Open of -20. On the surface a birdie-barrage looks more entertaining than hacking out of knee-deep cabbage.

However, what the run-and-gunners  and birdie fanatics miss is an appreciation for the strategy options and execution that turn an expected outcome on its head. Maybe what irks Virginia’s detractors the most is that Virginia wins enough big games now, that after a beatdown of UNC, no one even considered storming the court…since Virginia has now done this 5 times in a row.

I am not asking everyone to be a Virginia fan. All I am asking is for an accommodation, for a grudging acceptance that there is more than one way to succeed mightily in college basketball. Virginia might be an acquired taste, I understand that, but so is good bourbon, good scotch, and stout beer. Beating the tar out of the Heels two years in a row is a great reason to celebrate the acquired tastes in life, wherever we find them.

Saban and his Achilles' Heel: The Kicker

Here are four words an Alabama fan never thought they would hear them self say in consecutive order:

 I. Miss. Cade. Foster

Oh Cade, How we miss you...
Oh Cade, How we miss you…

I’m sure these four words have been placed into other sentences over time. For instance after last year’s Iron Bowl, one may have heard “I just saw Cade Foster miss 3 field goals, and now I hate everything.” But when the season ended in January with a lackluster performance and loss to Oklahoma, there is not a single Alabama fan that wished they could have one more season of Cade.
That was before they tuned into ESPNU for the 2014 A-Day game, and watched Adam Griffith attempt to kick a field goal. People often forget that it was not Foster who missed the last kick against auburn, but young Adam Griffith, the man who will most likely be taking every snap as Alabama’s starting place kicker in 2014. Alabama is in trouble.
I am probably being a bit unfair in my premature judgment of Griffith, after all a 50+ yard kick to win the Iron Bowl as time expires is hardly an ideal situation for a player to be introduced to the Alabama fan base. And, it’s entirely possible the poor outing at A-Day was just a fluke, but let’s take a minute here to explore the history of kickers under Nick Saban.
As much as non-Alabama fans hate Nick Saban, most rational college football fans would admit he’s the best coach in in the college game, and most Alabama fans would admit he’s the closest living thing to a deity on this Earth. He’s accomplished this with great coaching and discipline, but mostly by out-recruiting everyone else in the game.  According to most services he has finished with a top 5 recruiting class in each full year as head coach at Alabama. That has translated into 3 National Championships, 2 SEC Championships, 41 NFL draft picks, 15 first round picks, 19 consensus All-Americans, 1 Heisman winner, and countless other award winners. If you read my previous article, then you know I claim he’s the best recruiter in the history of college football (Spurrier said it first). Nick Saban has been a machine when it comes to convincing high-schoolers to move to Tuscaloosa, but there is one thing Saban has never done at the university: recruit a good Field Goal kicker.
Under Saban four kickers have received full athletic scholarships to play for the Crimson Tide, and so far not one of them has panned out. We all know about Foster’s troubles, Corey Smith transferred without ever playing a meaningful down at Alabama, We are now beginning to see the struggles of Griffith, and I have no idea who  Jay Williams is. There have only been 2 mildly reliable kickers to play for Nick Saban and Alabama: Leigh Tiffin and Jeremy Shelley, the former being a Mike Shula player and the latter being a walk-on who was only reliable inside 40 yards.
In a year where the crimson tide are replacing a 2 time national championship quarterback, 7 defensive starters, two veteran offensive lineman, one might think there would be more pressing issues than writing an 800 word article on the field goal kickers at Alabama. But Tide fans have personally witnessed this portion of the game cost the team wins, and yet we have seen no improvement in the players brought in.
We’ve seen Saban change his recruiting strategy from bringing in huge front 7 athletes, to recruiting more fast-twitch players to adapt to spread offenses. We’ve seen him change offensive coordinators to find more creative ways to get the ball to his playmakers. But so far, we have seen zero change in placekicking.
It’s baffling that a proven talent evaluator such has Saban has struggled with finding an elite kicker, but for whatever reason, he has. If I’m Saban I’m posting an ad on craigslist inviting every former high school kicker or soccer player with college eligibility remaining to come in for an open tryout, because whatever he is doing to evaluate these guys is clearly not working. Perhaps this is why he constantly takes to the podium telling the fans they complain about the kicking game too much. He knows the one thing he’s bad at, and doesn’t want the media pointing it out to all his worshipers. Well listen up Nick, if you don’t give us anything to complain about, then we will be forced to search for something. Complaining about shit is part of what makes sports fun. (Trust me, I know; I’m also an Atlanta professional sports fan) We’ve all found your flaw and we plan to expose it until you do something about it. It’s why they call us fanatics.

Follow Jake on Twitter @Jake_Kline.